Karl Dinkler

Plain Spoken

4 minute read.

The long version

Seven years with Lake Highland’s Office of Advancement, and what staying that long did to the work.

Most of my strategy engagements last a few weeks. I build a brand or a launch, hand it off and move on.

My work with Lake Highland Preparatory School lasted seven years, from 2019 to 2026, with the school’s Office of Advancement and a capital campaign called Elevate. The school set out to raise forty million dollars, and it did. The case study covers what we made. This is about what staying that long did to the work, and to the way I think about clients.

Discovery

Discovery meant research into how giving worked at the school, what the campaign was meant to pay for, and who it was all for. What it turned up was a belief the school already held and had never written down, so I put it into words.

From the 2020 pitch to Lake Highland’s Office of Advancement:

Being a Highlander is forged over one’s time at Lake Highland Preparatory School.

Once a Highlander. Always a Highlander.

Next, the pitch quoted a line usually credited to Margaret Mead, about a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens changing the world. Here the small group was the school’s own students, faculty and staff, the people who were going to change the world. From there the thesis was one sentence.

The world needs more Highlanders.

I wrote it into the pitch and then into the brand guide in 2020, along with the voice, the tagline, the color and the logic underneath it all. Six years later the premise is still standing, and it still runs through the campaign site.

Most brand lines get retired inside a few years. Softened, hedged, replaced by a committee that meant well. A line survives that long only when it was true before it was written down.

Where the line went

The first time I heard it from someone outside the team, it was a member of the campaign board, giving a speech. Today Lake Highland uses it in its own marketing and communications, in its own voice, and most people who repeat it have no idea it started on a page in a 2020 pitch.

In 2023 I walked into the Porter Family Center for Innovation & Academics: 71,000 square feet, full of students. Three years earlier it had been a goal in a campaign plan.

We were never selling

The brand guide has a passage on posture and voice. It says the campaign should persuade through its relationships, and that if a piece starts to feel like a sales pitch, something has gone wrong. We believed it when I wrote it, and it was the strategy.

Fundraising done well is a relationship that happens to involve money.

Watch a good advancement team and you stop seeing asks. You see people who know each family, who remember the kids and what they are good at, and who show up when there is nothing to collect. The money moves toward that.

Clients can be partners

What was true of the donors turned out to be true of me. Early on, the Advancement office stopped being a client and became a group of people I wanted to do good work for. They worked through relationships in everything they did, and they believed in what they were building. That made the work more demanding, because you cannot phone it in for people you respect.

By year three I understood the school better than any brief could have told me, and the work got better for it. When the people I had worked with moved on, I handed everything over to the school, and the campaign has gone on without me at elevate.lhprep.org.

I have done transactional work. It pays. It also ends the day the invoice clears, and it teaches you little you did not already know walking in.

Karl Dinkler is VP, Creative Strategy and Design Leadership at NEXUS Luxury Collection, a Tavistock Group company, and founder of the studio Anon. He has spent twenty years in luxury hospitality and real estate.

From the work

Next in Plain Spoken