Karl Dinkler

Plain Spoken

4 minute read.

Liberty through constraint

A line I heard at Wired in 2010, and why I’ve treated the limits of a project as the brief ever since.

In 2010 I was a few years into running creative for the Tavistock Cup and for Albany, the resort in the Bahamas that opened that year, all of it out of Orlando. I needed a bigger set of exposures, so I flew to New York for a few days to go get some. It was a whirlwind trip, the kind you take when you can feel your own reference points going stale and you go looking for new ones.

One of the scheduled stops was Wired. I sat with a few people from their creative and public relations team, and somewhere in the conversation one of them repeated a line that had come down from their new creative director: finding liberty through constraint.

The phrase is theirs. I heard it in that room, from the people in it, and I’ve been borrowing it for most of my career without saying where it came from.

Say you know an issue is going to be red. (That was how they explained it, and I’m paraphrasing years later.) You could spend the issue working around red, or surviving red, or sneaking a little blue in where nobody’s looking. The question was how to make a reader see red, feel red, in a way they never have before.

The red was the assignment.

I went up there chasing inspiration, the big vague thing I thought I was short on. I came home with something smaller and far more useful: four words about how to stand in front of a problem.

The same wall, two ways to see it

Any limit can be read two ways. One person looks at it and sees walls closing in on the work. Another looks at the same limit and sees a lane, a place to aim everything they’ve got without wasting a second wondering where the edges are. The wall is real in both cases, and what changes is whether you spend the project pushing against it or aiming down the lane beside it. The most freeing sentence in design might be “you can’t,” because once you know what you can’t do, you know where to aim.

The startup that had no walls

My clearest example runs the other direction: a constraint I had to go and find myself.

A few years ago Flaire, a startup building its first version, hired me as creative strategist through my studio, Anon. Flaire was a travel app by the time I was done. It was not a travel app when I started.

At the start it was a bit of everything: a place where young adults could connect with people they trusted, share the things they bought and loved, and get a quick honest answer from a peer. Good premise, with real energy behind it. But it had no walls. It was everything, for everyone, and everything-for-everyone is the hardest thing in the world to design, because there’s no edge to push against. Every screen could be anything, and every decision was wide open.

I wanted a constraint, something that would tell us what the app was for. It turned out one was already there, hiding in how people were actually using it. In the beta group the conversation kept bending the same direction, toward travel: places people had been and places they were dreaming about going. The advice they wanted from people they trusted was about where to go and what to do once they got there.

That was the lane. My advice was to take it, and Flaire’s founder made the call to go all in on travel. From there we designed and redesigned the product around that one use, and the traction the team had been reaching for showed up after the app narrowed to travel.

Walls I didn’t choose

With Flaire I went looking for a limit. In my day job the limits usually arrive on their own.

Three years before that trip to Wired, I already had a red issue of my own. When I took over the Tavistock Cup’s creative in 2007, Isleworth was red and Lake Nona was blue. The colors belonged to the clubs, not to me, and I had no business asking either one to give them up for a tournament. So we stopped designing around them and built everything out of them: flags, signage, uniforms, and the staff bags the players carried. When Albany joined in 2011 it came in pink and Queenwood came in green, and each new club brought its color into the system the same way. Six clubs still read as six teams from across the course.

The spectators finished the job. You wore your club’s color to the Cup, so by the end of the week the gallery behind the 18th green was a crowd of red and blue moving down the fairways. No sign we printed could have done that.

The other wall was the date. A tournament is a brand that lives for one week, and everything gets printed and installed against a day that does not move, with Golf Channel’s cameras on it. There is no second draft. That sounds like pressure, and it is, but it also settles every argument about whether something is finished. The Hero World Challenge at Albany still runs on that date every December, and it is still the most useful line in the brief.

The blank page

People assume a blank page is the scariest thing a designer faces. For me it’s usually the easiest problem on a project, because it comes right before the constraints show up to help. Give me a real limit, a budget that won’t stretch or a site that won’t move, and I’ll show you where the work wants to go.

Sixteen years on, I still start every hard problem the same way. I go looking for the lane.

Karl Dinkler is VP, Creative Strategy and Design Leadership at NEXUS Luxury Collection, a Tavistock Group company, and founder of the studio Anon. He has spent twenty years in luxury hospitality and real estate.

Next in Plain Spoken