Karl Dinkler

Plain Spoken

6 minute read.

Faster, cheaper, scattered

What twenty years inside private club, resort and residential portfolios taught me about the cost of decentralizing creative, and the case for keeping one hand on the brand.

Spread the work out on a table and you can see it in about four seconds.

Picture an owner with a golf club, a hotel and a set of residences, which describes a good share of this business. The golf club’s collateral, from one team. The hotel’s campaign, from another. The residential brochure, from a firm that only touches high-end real estate. Every one of those calls was reasonable the day it got made. Line them up and the type doesn’t match, the photography has three personalities, and the voice in the club newsletter belongs to a different company than the residential brochure.

It makes no difference whether that work came from five outside agencies or five in-house teams down the same hallway who never compare notes. The table looks identical. I’ve watched it happen both ways. The trouble starts with where the decisions get made, and in a scattered portfolio they get made in separate rooms.

Why portfolios decentralize

For a long time this happened by accident, one reasonable hire at a time, until somebody laid everything out and saw it. Now a lot of it happens on purpose. Each division hires its own agency or builds its own in-house team, and each property runs its own campaigns. The logic is easy to like. It’s faster, because nobody waits on a central queue. It looks cheaper, because the spend is spread out and local. And it lets each team make work that fits it. All of that is true, and the bill still arrives a few years later. From the inside, everybody is doing good work. From the outside, the portfolio reads as a company still deciding what it is.

Speed is real at first. Each team moves without waiting on anyone. Follow it out a few years, though, and the time saved by skipping alignment gets paid back with interest, as repair work: the rebrand three years out to fix the drift, or the campaign redone because it was fighting the one running next door.

Cheaper is mostly a feeling. Spread the spend across divisions and it gets harder to see without getting any smaller. Five teams solving the same brand problem from scratch means paying for it five times and getting five answers that don’t fit together. Pull the thinking into one place and it usually costs less, and the brief that comes out of it is better.

What’s fixed and what flexes

That leaves autonomy, the third argument, and under it sits a worry people rarely say out loud: hand creative to a central team and every property ends up looking alike. That fear is fair. An owner with a club worth joining does not want it flattened into a template.

Every asset in a real portfolio has an identity worth protecting. Take a beach resort and a city club under the same owner: they’re talking to different people on different days. One initiative inside a nonprofit is talking to a different donor than the one sitting right next to it. Those pairs should be related, recognizably one family, while each keeps talking to its own people.

What gets you there is architecture, and it’s the part of the job I love most. What’s fixed and what flexes. What holds across every asset and what bends to the audience or the cause. Where the parent brand lives, and how much of it each property has to carry. Get that right and each one gets more room to be itself, because it’s building on the strength of the family.

My high school choral director came back to one rule more than any other: the moment the audience could pick out a single voice, we had fallen apart. There were more than 200 of us, each expected to sing our own part fully, and all of it had to arrive as one sound. It took me years to see that he was teaching brand architecture and didn’t know it.

CAFO

One of the clearest examples I’ve built was for a nonprofit.

CAFO is a nonprofit alliance for vulnerable children: a parent organization and eight initiatives, each of which had drifted into a name, look and voice of its own. I had led creative strategy and design inside CAFO for years before I left, and in 2023 I rebuilt the parent and all eight initiatives into one architecture through Anon. Each initiative kept its own name, cause, audience and room to speak, and every one tied back to the parent, so a supporter could recognize the family at a glance across eight causes.

CAFO ran on a fraction of a luxury budget, and the problem was the same one. The hard part was the tie back to the parent, which had to read as family without making any initiative feel demoted to a sub-brand.

Who holds the standard

When an organization does try to hold the line, it usually reaches for a brand guide first: big, thorough, a beautifully made PDF. A guide tells people what to do, and it can’t make sure it happens. The next team opens it, takes its honest best guess at what it means, and turns in something compliant and slightly off.

In the portfolios where I’ve seen a standard hold, the decisions came early: the brief was shaped before a designer sat down, the shoot was art-directed before it happened, and the voice was set clearly enough that a writer could hear it without looking anything up. At NEXUS Luxury Collection most of that runs through NEXUS Studio, the in-house team I lead, which produces roughly 90 percent of the portfolio’s marketing and communication. Wherever that work sits, whoever leads it needs standing across every division, and the owner has to decide who that is before the next agency is hired, while the table is still empty.

The opposite failure is just as real. Push every asset through a single set of hands and everything slows down, and the properties start to look like photocopies of the parent. I’ve built the function that creates coherence, and I’ve also felt it tip toward uniformity and had to drag it back.

The standard also has to outlast the person holding it.

If it lives in one head, it walks out the door the day that person does.

So the real work is a brief good enough to travel without you, and a vocabulary the team knows well enough that it holds up when you’re not in the room.

Karl Dinkler is VP, Creative Strategy and Design Leadership at NEXUS Luxury Collection, a Tavistock Group company, and founder of the studio Anon. He has spent twenty years in luxury hospitality and real estate.

Next in Plain Spoken